Candidate Budget Scorecard Results
The Fix Trenton’s Budget committee created a multiple choice survey to assess the aptitude and policy perspective of Trenton’s municipal candidates. This was the committee’s major pre-election project. We hope it gives some perspective on the kinds of things that are necessary to fix the problem and the candidates who are most in tune with the correct solutions.
Dealing with Trenton’s budget in the long term means
- Having clear goals and focused priorities,
- Turning Trenton into a developer-friendly city,
- Re-tooling our tax system to stimulate investment and to be fair
- Putting a budget process in place that lets our city adapt to change
We weighted the question areas as follows
- Budget goals and levels at 30%,
- Development issues at 40%,
- Re-balancing at 20% and
- Budget process at 10%.
Scores were between 1 and 10. “No answer” got a zero.
Below are the results of our Scorecard survey.
Christine Donahue and Jim Carlucci both scored well in the At Large race. Carlos Avila was the only respondent from the South Ward. Eric Jackson and Frank Weeden did best in the Mayor’s race. Roland Laird gave the best responses in the North Ward. Kevin Moriarity was the only respondent in the West Ward. Verlina Reynolds-Jackson was the only respondent in the East Ward but is far out of alignment with our budget priorities.
Candidates who didn’t respond either don’t have clear positions and know it or are don’t consider it a priority. The survey took 15 minutes to complete, shorter than many canvassing visits. The Budget Committee doesn’t recommend any of these candidates.
Candidate | Score | Position |
Best Score Possible | 100% | |
Christine Donahue | 85% | At Large |
Jim Carlucci | 83% | At Large |
Carlos Avila | 82% | South Ward |
Eric Jackson | 79% | Mayor |
Frank Weeden | 78% | Mayor |
Roland Laird | 77% | North Ward |
Kevin Moriarty | 73% | West Ward |
Algernon Ward | 71% | At Large |
Marge Caldwell-Wilson | 67% | North Ward |
John Harmon | 61% | Mayor |
T. Missy Balmir | 60% | At Large |
Annette Lartigue | 59% | Mayor |
Keith Hamilton | 56% | Mayor |
Verlina Reynolds-Jackson. | 47% | East Ward |
Juan Martinez | 36% | At Large |
John Vaughan, Jr. | - | West Ward |
Joyce Kersey | - | West Ward |
Zachary Chester | - | West Ward |
Crystal A. Smith | - | South Ward |
George Muschall | - | South Ward |
Dennis Vereen | - | North Ward |
Divine Allah | - | North Ward |
Marvin W. Ford | - | North Ward |
Alex Brown | - | Mayor |
Manny Segura | - | Mayor |
Paul Pintella | - | Mayor |
Shahid Watson | - | Mayor |
Tony Mack | - | Mayor |
Errick Wiggins | - | East Ward |
Joseph Harrison | - | East Ward |
Kesner Dufresne | - | East Ward |
Zane Dion Clark | - | East Ward |
Alex Bethea | - | At Large |
Darren Green | - | At Large |
Donnelle Presha | - | At Large |
Ernest Perez Jr. | - | At Large |
Kathy McBride | - | At Large |
Phyllis Holly-Ward | - | At Large |
This is wack. What next, a poll to see if the candidates can “fight crime.” Come on!!! Truthfully, only the top 3 have respectable numbers. I would hate to have my child bring home a 79% in accounting!!
I’m sure this was created by some Mill Hill people who are out of touch with Trenton and really think they are relevant. Just because a candidate didn’t respond does not mean they don’t have clear positions and know it or don’t consider it a priority. That is so arrogant of you all to say that and to think that your recommendation for NOT considering someone matters..lol
(And check your site for typos while your at it).
It’s hard to imagine what the above two commentators are thinking.
They apparently believe that maintaining a sustainable city isn’t important. The reference to Mill Hill is odd given that that neighborhood is one of the few middle class areas in the city.
Perhaps the upshot is that Trenton should be left to the poor and doesn’t need tax revenue. Given that the State has grown weary of subsidizing Trenton’s budget, lac of tax revenue will lead to a cut in services, notably police, which will further drive away the middle class (as it has for the last 30 years).
Is it arrogant to want better. What’s out of touch about wanting to preserve a decent society in Trenton.
The commentators seem like the very people who have supported Trenton’s decline and would welcome its further decline through inattention to the city’s fiscal state of affairs.
Our committee hopes to shine a light on the “head in the sand” approach many Trentonians have been taking towards our budget. I’ve let these “un-signed” comments be published as an example of the attitude responsible citizens need to repel.